Cheryl leads me to the far wall of her living room where, beneath a woodblock print of Hemingway is a photo of the key and keychain he used to enter her family’s cabin. On the tag, Hemingway has typed: “The House of Hemingstein. Across the woods and damn near in the creek.”
Hemingstein is a nickname he used for himself since his high school days, when he and his friends would pretend to be Jewish pawnbrokers. Even late in his life, he would sometimes sign letters to friends as Hemingstein. The rest of it was a decent description for where Cheryl’s family cabin, the Heiss house, was located. Not anymore. After the family sold the lot in 2002, the cabin was picked up and moved south of town, joining a collection of log homes tucked behind the Mountain View gas station. The lot itself isn’t across the woods anymore. It’s a dense development of stone-and-timber homes selling for upwards of $3 million, across the street from a gourmet eatery.
Cheryl hails from Ketchum’s Heiss family, a longtime ranching family in the Big Wood River Valley. The white cowhide sofa I sit on is from one of their cows, branded C over Lazy 8.
“It was my dad’s brand,” Cheryl says.
The family is intimately tied to Ketchum history. The Heisses sold most of the land to the Sun Valley Corp. for the new ski resort. The cabin Hemingway stayed in was a ski cottage they used for the holidays.
Hemingway had another keychain, Cheryl said, with a more cryptic riddle written on the tag. “The den of the pure gamble,” it said. It was a phrase that hadn’t made much sense to her at the time. How could her family’s old cabin, where they celebrated Christmas each year, be any kind of gamble? Looking back, it began to make sense. Next year, Ketchum would see its oft-visiting author was at the end of his line. Whatever it was Hemingway was typing standing up at the dresser in the Heiss cabin, looking out over Bald Mountain, must have seemed weightier to him than anything he had written before.
“I’m writing well,” Cheryl remembered him telling her family. He had been renting the cabin through the fall and wasn’t too pleased when they told him they would be moving in for the holidays and he would be moving out.
Still, he came around often enough. He had winged an owl on a hunting venture and had taken him in as a pet. The bird was known simply as Owl. Hemingway kept the bird in the Heisses’s garage even after he moved out, and he came back to feed him. Cheryl was an Idaho State English literature major, but not much of a Hemingway fan. She was nonplussed by the famous author living in her family’s cabin. Celebrities were as common as snow in Sun Valley. Her friends were thrilled.
She was in her underwear when she first met him. Her family had just come back from a day of skiing. Cheryl had come inside and stripped down to her red long johns when the door bell jingled. Cheryl opened it expecting to see her father loaded down with ski gear. Instead, it was the Nobel laureate wanting to feed his owl.
“I slammed the door in his face,” Cheryl laughed. She came back more appropriately attired and let him enter. “The first time he walked in I thought he was bigger than life, with a booming voice, and very masculine,” she said. “And he wasn’t. He was very soft-spoken.”
She and her friends would come back from time to time that winter, and cajole Hemingway into sitting down and sharing a bottle of wine with them. In retrospect, he seemed lonely, she said. He came to the house when he knew people would be home, and he was happy to linger and chat.
“We just had absolutely no clue that he was at the end of his rope,” she said. “Nobody did.”